Saint Cecilia's Nursing Home
At a Glance
The information you need to decide whether this home warrants a closer look.
Nursing homes, Homecare agencies
Staff warmth score
of reviewers answered yes
Good to know
- Registered beds44
- SpecialismsCaring for adults over 65 yrs, Dementia, Learning disabilities, Physical disabilities, Sensory impairment
- Last inspected2021-10-20
- Visit Website
The Evidence
What the review data, the inspection reports, and the dementia-care evidence base tell us about this home.
What families say
Families talk about feeling genuinely included in daily life here. They describe staff who take time to understand each person's needs and preferences, creating moments of connection through organised activities.
Based on 9 Google reviews · 0 reviews on carehome.co.uk · most recent 2026-04-10
The eight family priority themes
- Staff warmth72
- Compassion & dignity72
- Cleanliness70
- Activities & engagement65
- Food quality60
- Healthcare68
- Management & leadership75
- Resident happiness70
What inspectors found
Inspected 2021-10-20 · Report published 2021-10-20 · Inspected 4 times in the last three years
Is this home safe?
{"found":"The Safe domain was rated Good at the September 2021 inspection, an improvement from the previous Requires Improvement rating. This domain covers staffing levels, medicines management, infection control, and the prevention of harm. The published summary does not record specific observations about night staffing numbers, agency staff usage, or falls management processes. No concerns or breaches in this area are noted. The improvement from the previous rating suggests the home addressed whatever safety issues had been identified.","quotes":[],"family_meaning":"A Good rating in Safe is a meaningful baseline, but the Good Practice evidence base consistently shows that safety is most fragile after 8pm, when staffing is thinnest. Our family review data identifies staff attentiveness as a driver of confidence for roughly 14% of positive reviewers, and that attentiveness depends heavily on having enough permanent staff on duty. Because the published report gives no staffing numbers, you cannot verify this from the inspection alone. The improvement from Requires Improvement is genuinely encouraging, but ask for specifics before deciding.","evidence_base":"The IFF Research and Leeds Beckett University rapid evidence review found that night staffing ratios are among the strongest predictors of avoidable harm in care homes. Homes that are Good by day can still have thin cover overnight, and the inspection may not have captured that detail.","watch_out":"Ask the manager to show you the actual staffing rota for a recent week, covering day and night shifts. Count the permanent names versus agency names, particularly on the overnight shifts for all 44 beds."}
Is the care effective?
{"found":"The Effective domain was rated Good, covering training, care plans, healthcare access, and food. Dementia is listed as a registered specialism, which implies some level of dementia-specific practice. The published summary does not describe the content or frequency of staff training, the detail of care plans, how often GPs visit, or what mealtimes look like. No shortfalls in this area are noted. As with Safe, the move from Requires Improvement means the home previously fell short of Good in this domain and has since made changes.","quotes":[],"family_meaning":"Dementia-specific training is one of the most important things you can probe when visiting. Our Good Practice evidence base, drawing on 61 studies, found that dementia training quality varies enormously between homes: some staff receive a half-day online course and some receive sustained, supervised learning. The Effective rating tells you inspectors were satisfied, but not what the training actually covered. Food quality is rated by roughly 20.9% of positive family reviewers as a key signal of genuine care. Ask to see a sample menu and, if possible, visit at a mealtime to see how staff support residents who need help eating.","evidence_base":"The Leeds Beckett rapid evidence review found that care plans function as living documents in higher-performing homes, reviewed with families at least quarterly and updated after any change in condition. Static care plans, filed and rarely revisited, are a warning sign.","watch_out":"Ask to see a sample care plan (anonymised if needed) and ask how recently it was reviewed and whether the resident's family was involved in that review. Also ask what dementia training staff complete and how often it is refreshed."}
Is this home caring?
{"found":"The Caring domain was rated Good, covering staff warmth, dignity, respect, and how staff support independence. No specific inspector observations, resident quotes, or relative testimony are reproduced in the published summary for this domain. The Good rating indicates inspectors were satisfied with what they saw, but the absence of specific evidence means it is not possible to confirm from the published report alone how this looks day to day. No concerns about dignity or respect are recorded.","quotes":[],"family_meaning":"Staff warmth is the single biggest driver of positive family reviews in our data: 57.3% of families who leave positive reviews mention warm and friendly staff by name. Compassion and dignity follow closely at 55.2%. These are not abstract qualities. They show up in specific observable behaviours: does a carer knock before entering a room, use your parent's preferred name rather than a generic term, and sit at eye level rather than standing over them? A Good rating in Caring is a promising sign, but because the report contains no specific examples, you need to observe these interactions yourself on a visit.","evidence_base":"The Good Practice evidence base highlights that non-verbal communication matters as much as verbal when caring for people with advanced dementia. Staff who move slowly, make eye contact, and respond to body language rather than just words create measurably better outcomes for distressed residents.","watch_out":"When you visit, watch how staff greet residents in a corridor or common area. Are they moving at the resident's pace, using names, and making eye contact? Ask the manager what name your parent would be called and how that preference would be recorded and communicated to all staff, including agency workers."}
Is the home responsive?
{"found":"The Responsive domain was rated Good, covering activities, individual engagement, and how well the home responds to each person's preferences and needs. The published summary does not describe specific activities offered, how activity programmes are tailored to individuals with dementia or physical disabilities, or what is available for residents who cannot join group sessions. No concerns in this domain are noted. The home supports several specialisms including dementia and physical disabilities, which implies a need for varied and adapted approaches to engagement.","quotes":[],"family_meaning":"Activities matter more than many families initially expect. Our review data shows that resident happiness is a theme in 27.1% of positive reviews, and Good Practice evidence consistently links meaningful activity with reduced agitation, better sleep, and slower functional decline in people with dementia. A Good rating in Responsive is encouraging, but group activities alone are not sufficient for everyone. If your parent has advanced dementia or limited mobility, ask specifically what would be offered to them on a day when they cannot join a group session. Everyday tasks, like folding towels, watering plants, or sorting objects, can be as valuable as structured activities.","evidence_base":"The IFF Research and Leeds Beckett review found that Montessori-based and task-based individual engagement approaches show strong evidence for improving wellbeing in people with dementia, particularly those who are no longer able to participate in group activities.","watch_out":"Ask to see the activities planner for the past two weeks, not just the upcoming schedule. Then ask what happened yesterday for a resident with advanced dementia who could not join a group session. If the answer is vague, probe further."}
Is the home well-led?
{"found":"The Well-led domain was rated Good, with a named registered manager and nominated individual confirmed in post. The improvement from Requires Improvement to Good across all domains is the clearest evidence of leadership effectiveness available in this report. The published summary does not describe how the manager is visible on the floor, how staff are supported to raise concerns, or how the home gathers feedback from families and residents. No governance concerns are noted.","quotes":[],"family_meaning":"Leadership stability is one of the strongest predictors of quality in our Good Practice evidence base. A manager who has been in post long enough to drive a turnaround from Requires Improvement to Good is a meaningful positive signal. Our family review data shows management and leadership feature in 23.4% of positive reviews, often described in terms of whether families feel listened to when they raise a concern. The key question for you is how long the current manager has been in post and whether the improvements are embedded or still fragile. Communication with families is a theme for 11.5% of positive reviewers: ask specifically how the home would contact you if your parent had a fall or a change in health overnight.","evidence_base":"The Leeds Beckett rapid evidence review found that leadership stability is one of the strongest predictors of sustained quality improvement. Homes where the manager changed frequently showed higher rates of regression after inspection.","watch_out":"Ask the manager directly: how long have you been in this role, and what was the main change you made after the previous inspection? A confident, specific answer suggests embedded improvement. A vague answer is a reason to ask more questions before deciding."}
Source: CQC inspection report →
What the evidence base says
Against the DCC Good Practice in Dementia Care standards, this home’s evidence aligns most strongly on The home provides specialist support for people with sensory impairments, physical disabilities and learning disabilities. They also care for people living with dementia, with staff trained to provide the understanding and patience needed.. Gaps or open questions remain on For residents with dementia, the team works to maintain familiar routines and create calm, reassuring environments. They understand how important it is to preserve dignity while providing the specialist care each person needs. — areas worth probing directly during a visit.
The DCC Verdict
Our editorial view, built from the three lenses: what families tell us, what inspectors record, and how the home sits against good dementia-care practice.
DCC Family Score
St. Cecilia's Nursing Home scores 72 out of 100, reflecting a genuine and encouraging improvement from its previous Requires Improvement rating to Good across all five domains. The published inspection report contains limited specific detail, so scores reflect confirmed positive direction rather than rich observational evidence.
Homes in Yorkshire & Humberside typically score 68–82.The three-lens summary
What families tell us
Families talk about feeling genuinely included in daily life here. They describe staff who take time to understand each person's needs and preferences, creating moments of connection through organised activities.
What inspectors have recorded
The nursing team focuses on keeping families connected and informed about their loved one's care. Recent changes mean the home is working through some communication challenges that they'll need to address.
How it sits against good practice
Getting to know a care home properly takes time — visiting in person helps you understand if it feels right for your family.
Worth a visit
St. Cecilia's Nursing Home on Filey Road in Scarborough was rated Good at its inspection in September 2021, published October 2021, with Good ratings across all five domains: Safe, Effective, Caring, Responsive, and Well-led. Crucially, this represents a step up from a previous Requires Improvement rating, which tells you the leadership team identified what was going wrong and fixed it. That improvement trajectory matters as much as the rating itself. The main limitation of this report is that the published summary is brief and contains very little specific observational detail: no direct quotes from your parent's future neighbours, no description of what staff were actually seen doing, and no specifics about staffing numbers, mealtimes, or activity programmes. A Good rating is meaningful, but it cannot substitute for a visit. When you go, ask to see last week's staffing rota (not just the template), watch how staff interact with residents in the corridor, and ask the manager directly how many permanent carers work overnight.
The three questions to ask when you visitSave this home. Compare it against your shortlist.
Let our analysis show you how Saint Cecilia's Nursing Home measures up against the other homes you’re considering. Free account.
In Their Own Words
How Saint Cecilia's Nursing Home describes itself — collected from its own website. DCC has not edited or independently verified the content in this tab.
Supporting families through life's changes with genuine care
St. Cecilia's Nursing Home – Expert Care in Scarborough
When someone you love needs specialist nursing support, finding the right place matters deeply. St. Cecilia's Nursing Home in Scarborough provides round-the-clock care for older people with complex needs. The team here works closely with families, keeping them involved and informed as their loved ones settle into this new chapter.
Who they care for
The home provides specialist support for people with sensory impairments, physical disabilities and learning disabilities. They also care for people living with dementia, with staff trained to provide the understanding and patience needed.
For residents with dementia, the team works to maintain familiar routines and create calm, reassuring environments. They understand how important it is to preserve dignity while providing the specialist care each person needs.
Management & ethos
The nursing team focuses on keeping families connected and informed about their loved one's care. Recent changes mean the home is working through some communication challenges that they'll need to address.
“Getting to know a care home properly takes time — visiting in person helps you understand if it feels right for your family.”
DCC does not edit or curate content in this tab. For independently curated information, see The Evidence and DCC Verdict.














